You are there vs. They are there


So what is the difference?  Do I have it right?

You are there: the vocal and soundstage starts at the plane of the speakers

                         and recess backward behind the speakers plane.

They are there: The soundstage is forward into the room with the vocal

                          reproduction in your room.

 

Which would you prefer?

andy2

Showing 3 responses by mylogic

If anything spatially changes a recording in any way…. the reproduction is flawed.
 

Is it not the goal of a very accurate hi-fi system to project just what is there and add noting more?. Surely any alteration is like colouring or sound processing similar to an AV amp, so not true to the original. 
 

We all know that “sound fields” in home theatre are not real but generated, so it must be best practice to use equipment that play nothing more than intended? Using equipment that adds and subtracts to the ambiance of the sound stage is questionably not true hi-fi.

@spenav ”How would you know the recording is changed unless you were at the recording studio or the live venue”

l would never know. I was talking about “if” a system did not actually reproduce the intended information or adds its own signature it is not true to the original.
 

“There is a difference in adding things or restoring things that were actually lost” 

I’m not sure if the “adding things” you refer to is in agreement with me or not, but the restoring things that ARE “actually lost” l am not sure is possible. The only way l would think you are talking about is maybe an extra recording element (or track that was part of the master) that has been recently rediscovered but was never included in the original mix?

An example that springs to mind of a lost, or in this case a rediscovered element is the 2.0 unlimited release of the soundtrack to “The Omega Man”  When the original first issue “limited edition” was released by Film Score Monthly 15 years earlier, it was not known that a third (centre) track of the keyboards/Synthesisers existed. The keyboards, a key (pun intended) important part of the score were quietly there on the original CD, but only recorded by the far left and right track microphones. Restoring the integral middle centre microphone elements with the higher keyboard levels brought the original soundstage ambiance back to that which was intended.

@kennyc  Optomize…. Optomize… Optomize is the best one (man) can do

 

Optomize…. Is to OPTOMIZE

A great beat going where?

If you care to dare

Optomize…. optomize until….

They are here, or YOU are THERE
 

Can anyone hear a great catchy song opportunity here?