XLR Interconnect as digital cable


I am aware of the problems doing this with RCA interconnects vs. digital RCA coax. Do the same problems apply with an XLR? Thanks
jl35

Showing 2 responses by almarg

Unless it is explicitly indicated that the particular cable is designed to provide the nominally 110 ohm characteristic impedance that is necessary for compliance with AES/EBU standards, or it is at least indicated that the cable is suitable for digital as well as analog applications, I would not count on it being anywhere close to 110 ohms, and I would avoid it.

For example, Blue Jeans Cable offers balanced cables utilizing "Belden 1800F, a highly flexible, low-capacitance AES/EBU cable suitable both for digital and analog use, and Canare L-4E6S, a 'star quad' cable suitable for analog usage only, with higher capacitance but also higher common-mode noise rejection." The 1800F cable is 110 ohms, but the Canare is only 44 ohms, which would result in a severe impedance mismatch in an AES/EBU application, which at the very least would stand a good chance of adversely affecting jitter.
03-12-15: Yping
Is that using an XLR as SPDIF or AES/EBU. SPDIF is a superior format to AES/EBU, imo...
A cable having XLR connectors would not be used for S/PDIF, which would be either RCA, BNC, or optical. And I very much doubt that a statement that S/PDIF is superior to AES/EBU is true in general, although it is certainly conceivable that there may be SOME cases where a S/PDIF connection between two specific pieces of equipment may provide results that are subjectively preferable to an AES/EBU connection between those same two pieces of equipment.

Regards,
-- Al
I'd be very surprised if any damage were to result. The only way I can envision damage occurring would be if the cable connected one of the two signals in the balanced signal pair (which would be on XLR pins 2 and 3) to ground (XLR pin 1), which would be highly unusual and probably indicative of a defect, AND if the output circuit of the component driving the cable could not tolerate a short to ground (despite the current limiting effect of its 110 ohm output impedance).

If you have a multimeter, or convenient access to one, you could easily check the cable for shorts (and open connections as well).

Regards,
-- Al