Wilson Audio Watt/Puppy 5.1

I've had mine since 1996 and while they don't sound dated, your question comparing them to the current Wilson speakers isn't apples to apples. If you have the money for the new models I'd go that way. But, I think your real question is do the 5.1's represent good value at $5500?

I have a vast amount of experience with this speaker. I can tell you it is very finicky. But, if you are willing to revolve your system and room around them, they can really sing. It has taken me a long time and much effort to get there, but my 5.1's still stand up to newer speakers and are far better than most.

Your problem, as was mine, will be whether or not your room and other components are compatable with the 5.1's. If they are, you'll be lucky. In the long run it may actually be cheaper to go with the Sophia which I suspect will blend more easily.

Insist on a home demo. Get at least two weeks to try them in your room. It's the only way to be sure. If they work, you can't do better for the money.

Xronx,

You're moving in the right direction. The 5.1's like warmer upstream components. But, I can almost guarantee you that treating your room to eliminate reflections and standing waves will be required. If your dealer sells ASC or similar room treatment devices have him bring some for you to experiment with. A room with relective walls and floors and Wilsons are not a good match.

They are not bass shy, but they have a tweeter that can be overly aggressive which is where the thin reputation comes from. Your room sounds like a pretty good match. If your dealer will give you a demo, by all means try them.