Will a record weight harm the motor in a direct drive turntable?


I've considered buying a record weight for my Denon DP-59L turntable, but I'm concerned that adding the weight would put added strain on the direct drive motor.  Does anyone have experience or advice with this?

aggie88

Showing 2 responses by larryi

Only the manufacturer can tell you how much additional weight is acceptable.  It is not so much the case that the weight would strain the motor's capacity to spin at the proper speed--significant extra torque would only be needed at startup even with a massive weight; it it the extra load on the bearing that would be of concern.  That extra weight could shorten the life of bearing or increase the amount of vibration (noise) generated by the bearing.

If you are concerned about the weight, you should look into clamps.  They don't weight as much and can do a better job of pressing the record tightly to the platter surface.  In particular, reflex clamps do a good job.  These clamps grip the spindle, and as you turn the knob on top, they apply increasing amount of downward pressure on the record label area.  To work as intended, a reflex clamp also needs a washer or o-ring around the spindle to actually raise the record up a little bit so that when downward force is applied beyond the washer or o-ring, the record is slightly bent; this bend causes a much larger area of the record being pushed into contact with the platter. 

Ideally, clamping and added weight is applied in conjunction with the design of the platter/mat.  The shape of the surface matters, and not all systems are designed to work best when the record is held in more forceful contact with the platter/mat.  Like everything in audio, one has to take trial and error risks; nothing is a universally positive tweak.  

Aside from trying to reduce the effects of a warp, record weights and outer rings are attempts to change the sound to tune it to one's preference.  It the weight more effectively couples the record to the platter/mat such that internal vibrations in the record itself are transferred more effectively to the platter and better damped (the usual intention of such weights) that MAY improve the sound, or it may make it subjectively worse; it really depends on what the rest of the system sounds like and what you are looking for in the sound.

I have Basis Debut table with a vacuum clamping system.  This is pretty much the ultimate way to couple a record to the platter to dissipate vibration in the vinyl that will feed back to the stylus.  If you place the stylus down on a record that is not spinning at tap the record surface with the back of a pen near the stylus, you can barely hear sound coming from the speakers.  If you do that with other tables you will hear much more of that vibrational energy being fed to the cartridge.  So, this is definitely a good thing?  Not necessarily.  Some people find this degree of damping to be excessive and subjectively "dead" sounding.  It really is system and personal taste dependent.  I've played my table with the vacuum off, and sometimes, I prefer the sound that way.