Why do turntables sound different?


Let's consider higher-end tables that all sound excellent. Same arm/cartridge and the rest of the chain. Turntable is a seemingly simple device but apparently not quite or not at all.
What do members of the 'scientific community' think?
inna

Showing 3 responses by moonglum

The Rockport treatise should be compulsory reading for anyone either contemplating the design of a turntable or who is merely interested in this issue. I am not a designer of HiFi equipment but it is a compelling, albeit lengthy, read.

The most salient point of the white paper is the assertion that the turntable platform/motor unit is responsible for “50% of the music signal”.

Why is that? Well, if you display an audio signal on an oscilloscope you will see it presented in 2 axes. The “Y” axis represents amplitude i.e. signal magnitude (this is the cartridge's responsibility) and the “X” axis represents the timebase i.e. the “timeline” of the music (this is the turntable's responsibility).

The speed stability of the T/T is instrumental in holding up its half of the bargain by maintaining this relationship with the other half of the signal.

Achieving that target both in the broad and transient sense is easier said than done, as the white paper will explain.

As has been highlighted by various contributors in the posts above, parasitic vibrations related to the T/T can also affect the cartridge’s ability to perform its function thereby complicating the situation even further.

This is why T/T “motor units” always influence the final sound.

In the early 1970s, I think Linn were the first to make the assertion that motor units sound different and started doing AB comparisons with other turntables to reinforce this fact in the public mind.

A summary....

For those who haven't seen this before, enjoy!


http://www.stefanopasini.it/Audio_Moncrieff.htm


NKonor, you are most welcome. :) :)

Here is a link to the full(?) article.

 

http://www.iar-80.com/page12.html

 

To make your T/T selection headache even greater, take a look at this You Tube clip. Even if you pipe this through a budget amp & speakers it will give you a flavour of the turntable’s capability.


Bob Wood has posted quite a few with this particular turntable plus at least 3 other tables. He also boasts, apart from his SPU collection, a fine collection of Soundsmith carts, amongst others.

This table, my personal favourite of the 4, is a rebuilt/restored Lenco idler drive built by a real craftsman and technologist. If you were looking for a top VFM purchase you couldn’t go wrong with an arrangement like this.

 

Not only does Bob superbly optimise & present the audio aspect of his turntables but he does a killer video edit as well. :)

I’m always keen to see the latest thing that he has posted.

This link will put you in touch with more needledrops…

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=untpS8wOx9k

 

Best regards,

Bill.