Why "bookshelf" sspeakers?


This is not a rhetorical question. I’m asking because I don’t know.

The question is this: What is the point of "bookshelf" style speakers if they are not going on a bookshelf or table? In other words they are on speaker stands.

Here is the reason I’m asking. For a short time I had a pair of Aerial Acoustics 5T speakers along with a pair of Aerial Acoustics 6T towers (which I still have).

I listened to each set of speakers through a Bryston AV amp. I felt like the 6Ts sounded much better. More bass. Fuller sound. (I think a subwoofer would have resolved that easily for the 5Ts.)

The 5Ts are not exactly small and would barely fit on most bookshelves (although they are front ported and recommended for bookshelves by AE). The ones I listened to were on heavy metal stands which made them almost as big and heavy as the 6Ts.

So why buy smaller speakers which need to go on large heavy stands that make them as big as a floor standing speaker and not sound as good? Space saving does not seem to be the answer and I see some ’bookshelf’ speakers that are a good bit bigger than the AE 5ts.

I’m sure there must be a good reason since I see many people with them. And of course my assumption that a floor stander sounds better than a bookshelf might be wrong.

I guess cost comes into play somewhere in the equation as well.

Interested in people’s thoughts on this.

n80

Showing 3 responses by ellajeanelle

When bookshelf speakers are placed on stands instead of a bookshelf or table there is more room for adjustment. The stands can be manipulated and placed away from the wall and the soundstage, depth etc. can be adjusted more accurately to one's liking, but the same can also be said for tower speakers. There is some truth in that the stand can help isolate the speaker from the floor (good for apartments and improved sound). Some stands resonate and can make things worse. Some put sand or lead inside the speaker stands.  It's really difficult generalize and say that bookshelves are better than towers or vice versa.  All things being equal, towers generally extend the low end more when compared to a bookshelf.  There are too many variables involved. 

The bookshelf speaker "thing" is fairly recent. They were not as common when I started this hobby in the 80’s as they are today. Budget, location, room size, neighbors or no neighbors, apartment or house, space, aesthetics, convenience, "the wife"/ (or husband) listening styles, music genres, playback volume, occasion and many other resons I’m sure.

Personally, I have a couple of each type in 6 different rooms. I like the bookshelves with 2 subs for background music and towers or the PA speakers for when I want to rock and get my fix!  

Obviously, my comment is brief and only scratches the surface.  If you can do it, why not have every combination and get the full experience? Life's short!

gdnrbob: I never had a bookshelf speaker until computers became mainstream. Bought my first pair of bookshelves when I got my first computer at a Radio Shack.

Personally, I don’t remember seeing many bookshelves back then. Everybody (at least in my circle) wanted 15" floor standing speakers on a short stand, or a pair of the now legendary Acoustic Research AR9 towers (still have mine)!

 

viridian: How are big speakers = big problem? I’ve had big speakers all my life and they have traveled with me all over the world during my numerous moves. Big speakers= big sound if you ask me, and there is just no substitute for what they can do.  If you don't have to why compromise? It's the equivalent of buying a mini refrigerator versus a full size one.