Whizzer cone removal


I've got a pair single driver speakers I've supplemented with a ribbon supertweeter and single cap crossover at 3khz. I'm just wondering about very carefully removing the whizzer and if anybody has tried this and if it worked to positive effect. Thanks!

fourwnds

Showing 7 responses by fourwnds

Thanks everyone. 

@dekay I'm not sure exactly what you mean. If you can and wouldnt mind can you send me a pic?

fourwnds@hotmail.com

@bache thanks for your input and experience regarding the whizzer situation. 

I get that I might be screwing the pooch here if I move forward with this. Why can't I leave well enough alone. I'm getting pretty great sound as it is. Curiosity killed the cat, or does fortune favor the bold, to be continued. . .  : )
@timlub thank you for your post. I’m curious and encouraged. First, why do you say a ribbon would not be happy crossed at 3k? What do you mean by 6db per octave. Sorry, my technical skills are matched by no one.
@ the above 2 posters. Let’s see the driver is a HempTone not a particularly exotic single driver or anything. At just about 3k according to the response graph things begin to start to get pretty squirrelly. I feel like there is a pretty seamless blend between the Fountek’s NeoX 2.0 but I’m no expert. The frequency response kicks in @ 1.2khz for the Fountek. Both speakers share same eff. I didn’t want to try anything there as I didn’t want to hear the tweet seperate from main driver but still utilize its goodness. I don’t know, Anyway I thought I start there and change value if it bugged me but shoot my hearing starts to drop off anyway much past 7k and it sounds pretty good. Thanks for your advice. 

@bache I will look into this, RTA, appreciate it. I guess it's  time to start getting serious about this, by that I mean seriously funner. I hope. Thanks bud. 

@timlub this is great information!  I just picked up a laptop and I'm going to get into this business soon. Much obliged.  Btw, I have since removed the whizzer and honestly I can't tell a bit of difference.  What I can say is that some speaker position refinement, by ear still, is making a dramatic difference(at least to me).  I thought I had it pegged but . . no.  The difference is the channel balance, reverb on the recording and a gestalt overall.  I have for a long time cheated the room with dual vol. control, and since picking up the Decware Torii, I have had to reckon with it.  Such a frustrating pain in the ass, but the difference between something not quite right but very listenable and oh there it is, is really what all the fussin is about
I found that removing the whizzer had zero effect. Already employed the super tweeter when I did it. Adding the s tweeter added some more air and detail but it wasn’t a night and day difference. The driver in these was not what Decware uses now or then and was a custom choice. But, I am happy with them. I’m sure one day I’ll change them. But for now they are great. Looking forward to how a deviation from Grado is going change the system sound at this point.