Which tubed cd player for this system


I am looking to get a cd player for my new system
speakers: Zingali 3S (horn/bass reflex)
preamp and amp are being built by Albert at space tech
tube Q113A, hybrid HP -100 amplifier
cd players considered (I can get all at approx the same cost new) Xindek SCD-2, Njoe Tjoeb 4000, or Jolida 100
I might be able to stretch the budget a little and try a Shanling cd-t 100 (sure looks nice!)
Obviously I am trying to stay tubed output
Thanks, your advice is welcome
dcktr

Showing 5 responses by muralman1

We just did this one a few topics down> "How does the Jolida JD-100 compare to..." Check it out. It's an eye opener.
Docjr8156, Siemens is the better tube. Mullards haze the sound. Also, I have heard things go terribly bad sonically with fancy wires. Having an open mind, though, I hope to hear the Ah! tjoeb some day.
Well, Socrates, you are holding out on us. State your problems with the Jolida, and that was with versus what? By the way....Phillips, not Burr Brown.
Bill Baker of Response Audio, who sells Jolida and other brands, was furious with me when I confronted him with the same criticisms you lay out . He yelled at me, “You are just the latest to bring me the bad news about their new Jolida 100, and that is after I implicitly told you to play the unit for at least fifty hours before calling me!” I didn’t buy the unit from Bill, but I’m glad I gave him a call before I sent the 100 back to Jolida Inc. I would have never known the joy I have listening to my system for hours a day.

I never was a believer in breaking in times. I always thought it was just another Audio neurosis. My experience with the Jolida has convinced me of the importance of breaking in Jolidas anyway. This Jolida certainly did respond to a lengthy break in. Thanks for reminding me how bad a green Jolida sounds like.

At least that explains the shallow and pinched stage. Many of your other complaints are the usual negatives surrounding a lot of 12AX7 tubes. I am no fan of those tubes either. The ones I choose to use are devoid of any of your criticisms.

The other major components in my system are Apogee speakers and Pass Labs X-600 monos. The Apogee Scintilla blows depth through the wall. It layers players from foreground to background as only the equally venerable Quad 63 can. The Jolida fully accommodates these delightful attributes. The Stage naturally extends the full width supplied by the speakers, with each player accurately situated.

Contrary to your review, my Jolida excels on female vocals, and males, babies, and cybers.

You are right, proper strike decay is essential to believability. I can’t say I have ever heard a straight solid state system get it right. There is always that digital brake at the end. Glad you like solid state.

The bass is as full and articulated as far as tubes go that I’ve ever heard. It satisfies my deep desire for good bass. The mids are to die for. Eva Cassidy never sounds brittle as she so often does on solid state players. Jane Monheit is as clear as a bell. Krall has that bit of smokiness, and Barber is so brooding.

Detail is all there, but fully integrated within the music, and not zippered out like many “high end” players. I hear all the breathiness of singers, individual beads rolling in a rattle, pipes that sound like pipes, wood, wood.

As for mechanical, it is a $900 machine for crying out loud. I am puzzled at your report of hearing transport noises during play. Neither I nor anyone else have heard anything of the like. Of course, none of us are sitting with the Jolida in our lap. The door is noisy and quick. I give it a demerit for that. I have seen cheaper machines that do that better. Those machines do not have a tube out stage. That, along with it’s linear Phillips chips raise it to a level that leaves so little for improvement. I know Wadia and Musical Fidelity owners that see the worthiness of this player. Yes, I said Phillips as do all sellers, and Jolida itself. I looked under the hood too.

I know I can’t expect you to take in a Jolida and keep it for an extended break in period, but I can tell you from having the same poor initial experience, you are wrong, so wrong. Here is some good advice: Give Bill Baker a call and tell him what you have told us.....then hang up quick before the lashing begins.
I apologize for underestimating your review preparation. Know too, I am not an "audiophool."

Your insistance the Jolida is lame leaves me befuddled. How is it your audition of that particular unit left you with such negative feelings, when the rest of us find the Jolida so good. If the machine you listened to had a Burr Brown chip on board, it may be it had been extensively modified.

The fact is, your summation of the Jolida is unique among all others I have read. I have read two reviews that even place the Jolida above the Cary in performance, by their owners.

There just isn't any audible haze, incoherrance, or excessive distortion with my unit. I wouldn't be acting so bull headed if your review held any water, where my hearing is concerned. Stand by your words, if you will, they just don't ring true to me, or to anyone that has heard my Jolida I've shared your review with.

I'm in California. If you are ever out this way, I invite you to drop in for a listen. Like I said, local owners of CDPs costing as much as fourteen times the Jolida admit my Jolida's worthiness. There is the distinct probability the tubes you used were all 12AX7 tubes, which will not give you that last degree of polish.