While there are numerous theoretical pros and cons to the design consideration of either a passive or active power conditioner, the manufacturers you list (AQ and Audience) have designed their equipment to mitigate negative effects and improve SQ. Both use high quality parts with excellent mechanical design quality. That said, and as you state, theoretically active conditioning can reduce peak power delivery and introduce broad band noise. I would assume from the literature that is why Nagra has both active and passive circuits in their design. Passive filtration theoretically can introduce resistance that limits instantaneous currents demand that impacts dynamics. The best manufacturers have mitigated the risk. For example, the Shuntata Denali has both low current and high current outlets, where the former for maximum noise filtration and the latter for maximum, instantaneous current demand. On a side note, the Nagra has a “current reservoir” to provide for instantaneous current demand. I cannot comment except I have also heard some say the Nagra limits dynamics in their opinion. For those that recommend regeneration, theoretically it is the way to go if you are in an area with line voltage fluctuations, but if not, conditioning is the way to go IMHO. For example, at my vaca home in Vermont with large voltage fluctuations its regeneration. In my home in the suburbs of NY where mains line noise in this densely populated area is more of a problem, conditioning is the way to go. So, in conclusion, and I know I will not really give you an answer:
- The theoretical pros and cons of passive vs active conditioning have been mitigated by reputable manufacturers like Audioquest, Audience, and Shunyata. You cannot state factually one is better than the other. It will come down to system integration and your perception of the improvements in SQ.
- If you are in an area with large mains voltage fluctuations, consider regeneration.
- While I personally prefer passive conditioning by Shunyata and Audience, and have both in my system, it is my preference. Please audition and make your own choice.