Which of these preamps should I get?


I'm currently considering the final item of my Stereo System, a pre-amplifier. My system is currently comprised by a pair of Dynaudio Audience 120, a Rotel RB-1070 Amplifier, a Rotel RCD-02 CD Player, and a JBL S120PII Subwoofer.

My possible choices of preamp are the McCormack TLC-1 and the Rotel RC-1070. While the Rotel maybe a better match for my system, the McCormack is an acclaimed preamp, and it would come faster and cheaper for me, as I'd have to import the Rotel (living in Brazil). So, should I go with the used McCormack, or get a Rotel from US?

Please post your thoughts on this,

thanks
jmabe

Showing 3 responses by stehno

I agree with Uriah. Even though Rotel amps are solid state, they are not exactly known for their edgy presentation.

In fact, Rotel amps are typically known for being a bit on the rich, warm, perhaps even dark side of life. The McCormack may be the better equalizer.

-IMO
Rotel amplifiers are a decent amp for the money. With what might be an overly light or bright speaker, a Rotel amp can compensate by giving a slightly rich and warm overall presentation.

As for the McCormack DNA 0.5? This is somewhat of a legendary amplifier. Several years ago, the DNA 0.5 was rated a competitive second to the highly touted $30,000 Krell Reference Standard amplifier. (I believe the DNA 0.5 sold new for less than $2k.)

The McCormack DNA-2 Limited Anniversary Edition was rated the best solid state amplifier by Peter Moncrief of IAR in 1998 and according to Mr. Moncrief, the LAE easily exceeds both the Krell and the DNA 0.5 but was substantially more expensive than the 0.5. (BTW, some place Mr. Moncrief head and shoulders over most other reviewers.)

A DNA-2 Revision A or a DNA 0.5 Revision A easily exceeds the performance of the off-the-shelf DNA-2 Limited Anniversary Edition.

In summary, the DNA 0.5 amp could be a very wise choice. A DNA 0.5 Revision A amp could be an even wiser choice.

-IMO
The quality of the power should most always be the first priority. Not the quantity.

-IMO