Without the specs of yr SUT, cable, phono, & cartridge, there cannot be a "best" place. I recommend you try your 1ST solution first, then the second, in the order you present them.
You should check for clarity of sound midrange upward, and dynamic impact. Choose a record accordingly. Don't worry about "liking" the sound for now. Regards
You should check for clarity of sound midrange upward, and dynamic impact. Choose a record accordingly. Don't worry about "liking" the sound for now. Regards