What three cd's would one keep from collection ?

The Essential Leonard Cohen
OK Computer--Radiohead
Physical Graphiti--Led Zepplin

That was tough. The last five to hit the bottom of the waste can:

Bridge of Sighs--Robin Trower
Aenema--Tool
There Goes Rhymin' Simon--Paul Simon
Til The Sun Turns Black--Ray LaMontagne
The Shepherd's Dog--Iron And Wine