I usually ask what they like and try to start off with a taste of that. Maybe a couple tracks and then throw in a few pieces that really perform! Maybe Supertramp, “School” from Crime of the Century (either HiRez digital or the record). Maybe Yes, “Roundabout” Fragile, from HiRez dsf./SACD file. Maybe some Neil Young “Comes a Tome “ or “Look Out for My Love” off Comes A Time from analog remaster vinyl. Sting “Island of Souls” from Soul Cages, 44.1 digital. Black Crows “She Talks to Angels” off Shake Your Money Maker, 44.1 digital file. Genesis “Firth of Fifth” off Selling England by the Pound”, dsf./SACD digital file. Jesse Cook “Beyond Boarders” off Beyond Boarders 44.1 digital file. And whatever else they like.
Of course I don’t play all these for everyone but just choose some tracks that the person may like. Doesn’t work if they hate the band or type of music. But sometimes the music they like is a terrible recording. Most of my friends aren’t really into classical much but maybe a little jazz or progressive rock, classic rock and varied other styles. I’m not stocked up on county or Nashville stuff. Sorry. Everyone has a different taste! So try to play to they’re taste if the recordings are good.