short answer... it's magic.
Somewhat longer announcement....
It seems to me just from the Ops initial post that experience also plays a significant role and not merely what devices are on hand or could be had if dreams could be handily realized.
Unless one is tone deaf or the easiest person on the planet to please, no ambiguous or haphazard set of audio appliances just thrown together is going to achieve a thoroughly involving level of musicality. Especially right off the
bat.
If such has been a past or present experience, rush out and buy at least one lottery ticket, as it looks like youre one lucky son of a gun.
The more experience one can attain, be it first handed, by trial or error, or just from the wisdom of others, its a necessity if the aim is to obtain such an end. Truly engaging, entertaining, and honest recreation of the music one chooses to audition must contain the soul of its author. The force of its intent. The excerpt has to capture the llistener with some indescribable net that seems woven out of pure magic.
Therefore, I think it safe to say a decent connotation for the term Musicality is that it is the sum of more than its more obvious and noteable segments .
it is the single most indescribable facet of music. It is life and breath were none could possibly be. Its the allure and intrigue that simply shouldnt occur.
Its that element that compels us to listen further for pleasure than to listen for and await possible anomolies. Its enjoyable and fascinating. Its a comfortable invitation to revisit favorable memories and adventure into some as yet unknown with eager anticipation. A quality that reaches well into the mind and touch the soul itself.
It could be put as simply as the Knee bobbing and toe tapping factor too, I suppose.
Winston Churchill's quotation, made in a radio broadcast in October 1939: wherein he fielded a question on future events regarding Russia and/or its intnetions
"I cannot forecast to you the action of Russia. It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma .but perhaps there is a key. That key is Russian national interest."
Musicality might very well be revealed as exactly that It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma
Whatever it actually is by ones definition, it sure is the aim and intended result so many audio enthusiasts ascribe to reproduce.