Fun topic, but meaningless. Sure, I have my entries in both categories (overrated KEF ls/50, underrated Vandersteen 3A Signature), but like all else in audio (and the world) it's a matter of personal taste. Vandersteen is never going to sound great to millercarbon, while they do sound great to me. Both valid views. Maybe the real takeaway from this discussion is the highly variable reliability of professional reviews.
Jim Heckman
Jim Heckman