Personnel I would buy used either brand..... You will get way more performance for your dollar.
Not familiar with the SOTA line but a lot of people really like them.
VPI, I would be looking at a used classic model (the VPI Prime would be 2500 used). Yes the classic and the Prime are much better sounding than the Scout. (owned a scout and have a Prime, heard the classic many times before)
In addition Audiogon has a Well Tempered Amadeus for $2200 buck. These always get rave reviews (don't be fooled by the looks do your research). Also this table requires virtually no cartridge setup for beginners and still manages to be awesome. (heard the simplex, would not fear the Amadeus is not on the level of these other tables)
I don't think you would regret any of these choices. Very few people have heard all these table (on same system) to give you a informed quality comparison. I would do research and pull the trigger if you don't have the dealers to make an informed choice.
Buy from audiogon, buy from a person with very good feedback and plenty of transactions, Don't over spend (research). Do all these things and you will be in good shape. .