Von Schweikert vs Wilson


Ayone compare VSA VR-4SR mkIII or VR-5Anniversary with Wilson Watt/Puppy 8? I have a 20' x 14.5' x 8' room. My system consists of:
-CJ CT-5 preamp
-Spectron Premiere 7 Power Amp
-Whest PS.30r Phono/modified VPI HW-19 MkIV TT/Ortofon Jubilee
-McIntosh MVP-871 player-modified by The Upgade Company
-all tied together with Transparent Ultra and Crystal Cable Standard.
I like all music except country and rap/hiphop. Strong tight and deep base with excellent dimension.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
lubes3

Showing 3 responses by lubes3

I went from 3A Sigs to the PBN EPS2s and, to me, the PBN are far superior, as in less veil, faster, greater resolution and transparency with a larger soundstage. I listened to the Quatro and I actually liked my 3A Sigs better.

Now, I have not heard the 5A only because I think they have the same midrange and tweeter as my 3A Sigs had. Again veiled compared to my current EPS2s.

I don't know if the Von Schweikerts will be better than my PBNs as they are difficult to audition. I have not heard the WP8, but have heard the Sashas which impressed me sonically, as well as visually. Its the WP7 or 8 or VSA VR4SE or VR5 SE I'm considering.

Thanks for your responses.
Hey guys. Thanks again for all your input.

Vandersteen makes agreat speaker, but since the 5A may have the same midrange as the 3As, and I was very impressed with the speed, transparency, and resolution of my PBNs, I decided to forego the 5As and audition the Wilsons.

I demoed the Sashas, no WP8 to audition, and thought they sounded fantastic. Though they are a little higher priced than I want to go, from the dealer and other posts, they should be similar to the WP8 which can now be found for less. I like tight, punchy bass with a very deep and wide sound stage. I have a fairly bright room so a little top-end roll-off may not be bad.

I've been discouraged from the VSAs for many reasons I won't go into now, plus no where to audition.

I found a great deal on a pair of Wilson WP8 and will have them 1/15. I'll keep you posted on my thoughts of their musicality within my system.
Mtdking,

It looks like you bought the WP8s in November. If they were new, how do they sound now? Mine will be new and I'm wondering how long they take to breakin in and smooth out.

Since I've only heard the Sasha, which I liked, but you didn't, I hope the WP8 will be more to my liking,as I hope they still are to you. How do you think they differ from the Sashas, now that you've had them for a couple of months? What speaker cables are you using?

Unfortunately, my Spectron amp is acting up and I may have to bring it in for service after CES (everyones is at CES now), around the time I pick-up the WP8s. Timing is everything. Maybe I'll play them with my old poolside Harmon Kardon receiver--Ouch!!

Keep me posted on your WP8s sound. Thanks guys.