Using cheap CD-R disc on Audio recorder


Did anyone use a computer cd-r disc to be burned on audio recorder player such as Pioneer or Philips ??
philc

Showing 3 responses by ramstl

Keis, the problem you are having with computer grade CDR's not playing in cd players that audio grade CDR's play in is very, very unusual. It has been my experience that once finalized there is no diference between the two regarding the ability to play back. Either the cd player will play CDR's or won't. I have had some experiences where a CD player will reject a certain brand of CDR's regardless of whether it is audio or computer. I'm not saying your experiences are false, just unusual. I would like to know more. BTW, I have burned over 2500 or more CDR's, for my use or others, with at least 10 diferant brands, old and new, made in USA, Japan or Tiwain, Audio or Computer with consistant result. Either the cd player plays CDR's or it doesn't. The discs I have recorded on computer grade cd's are happily spinning in no fewer than 20 diferant types of audio cd players and none of these have rejected them and accepted only audio CDR's. PSBTW, Some players will play CDR's but never play CDRW's. Apparently the laser in these decks are incapable of reading CDRW's. Let me know more about the problems you been having, that way I can, as well as others, learn to avoid them.
I believe it won't burn them due to the fact that it is a consumer CDR not a "pro" unit. This is common for all consumer models. However, I have heard that some new consumer models will accept computer grade. Although, that is just rumor at this time.
No. However, I haven't use any consumer CDR's. But I don't think there are any differencs between computer vs audio from the same manufacture. But, I could be wrong. I use Imations, they are cheap and come in a thin style case. Which saves room. I compare them to the master and I can't hear a difference on my system. Maybe on a $100,000 system I could but on my $20,000 I can't. Athough, I haven't done exhaustive listening. You see, I have to back up my recordings and at this time this is the best I can afford. At one time I read studies that were done on CDR media and it stated that there were only 3 or 4 manufactures of CDR media. At that time they were made in USA, Japan and Tawain. They stated that for the most part all of the CDR's made in Tawain did not survive the aging process very well. They said the Japanese were better and the USA were good. They named manufactures, but I forget who they were. I believe they mentioned memtek as one of the ones to avoid. They also mentioned that the real cheap bulk one are bad. They stated that Sony, TDK, Imations ect were good. However, this study was done 2- 1.5 years ago and quess what? All the manufacturing is done in Tawain now. The CDR's they stated were good are no longer made in the same manufacturing plants and have since moved to Tawain and since 80 minutes is the norm most of the dye has changed. I haven't seen or read a new study, but I would be interested in what is new. Anyway, I haven't had any problems with Imations.