I would agree with you (original poster). If I were shopping in that price range I'd look long and hard at the vpi classic. I'd match it to a dynavector 20x and spend the remainder on a good used phono stage (sorry, can't help you much there as I'm not really familiar with what's around in phono stages right now).
I'd also consider a used Michell Gyro with perhaps an SME 309 arm.
I'd also consider a used Michell Gyro with perhaps an SME 309 arm.