I have mixed feelings about this also.
I agree that this is probably the one item that I would consider being a risky purchase, if buying used. There is just so much that can go wrong buying a used cartridge.
However, that being said, I have bought three used cartridges:
A Dynavector XV-1S from a friend, (okay, that was a pretty much a safe bet),
One from a guy on Audiogon, (A Shelter 90X, which was in very good shape),
And even one from a guy on Ebay, (which while it did make me nervous, the Koetsu Rosewood Signature was in near mint shape). So, all things considered, it was a great way to save money. (I bought these for about 30-35% list price.)
If you deal with a person who you feel comfortable with, (especially if you've spoken to them, or if they post a lot here or on Audio Asylum), then you can probably get a decent deal. Buying from an unknown entity is likely to make for an anxious buying experience, but not necessarily a bad one.
My two cents worth.
I agree that this is probably the one item that I would consider being a risky purchase, if buying used. There is just so much that can go wrong buying a used cartridge.
However, that being said, I have bought three used cartridges:
A Dynavector XV-1S from a friend, (okay, that was a pretty much a safe bet),
One from a guy on Audiogon, (A Shelter 90X, which was in very good shape),
And even one from a guy on Ebay, (which while it did make me nervous, the Koetsu Rosewood Signature was in near mint shape). So, all things considered, it was a great way to save money. (I bought these for about 30-35% list price.)
If you deal with a person who you feel comfortable with, (especially if you've spoken to them, or if they post a lot here or on Audio Asylum), then you can probably get a decent deal. Buying from an unknown entity is likely to make for an anxious buying experience, but not necessarily a bad one.
My two cents worth.