Sorry to say that the atmas are not stand alone OTL tube amp but need output transformer plain and simple.
Thought on OTL tube amps
Just curious....how do these sound/perform compared to tube amps with transformers? Why do you prefer one or the other? Any particular brands of OTL amps you would recommend listening to? You can see my system on my tag here...listen mostly to rock and roll with a smattering of jazz and a bit of classical once in a while. The next stop on my amplifier adventure is an OTL model, and I have no intention of trading it for either SET I currently have, as I'm very happy with both. One of the ways I enjoy experimenting with different "sound" is by switching up the amps. Just trying to solicit some opinions, of which I know there are many strong ones here at A-Gon. Thanks in advance!
110 responses Add your response
realdeal, you are truly misinformed. I have run three different levels of the glorious Atma-Sphere OTL amplifiers S-30, M-60, MA-1 Silver on numerous loudspeakers with no issue whatsoever! All were played without autoformers, all were played through 8-16 ohm nominal impedance loads. It is abundantly clear that you have no proper, real life experience with these amplifiers. You really should do yourself (and the rest of us) a favor, and go out and get a good solid audition of these babies and then come back with an honest opinion. Happy Listening! |
The Zero autotransformer will not make amplifier output impedance and the speaker input impedance higher as Paul Speltz claim,It only decreases impedance on both input and output but it increase output power due to less impedance and more current.There's a lot of Paul explanation about the Zero are wrong. |
Realdeal, as I indicated in my response to the very similar comment that was made by Xonex77, that is simply not correct. A suitably designed autoformer can transform voltages and impedances no differently than a two-winding transformer can. Although there are obviously other differences between the capabilities of the two kinds of devices, most notably the obvious fact that an autoformer can’t provide electrical isolation. You (and Xonex77) may want to read up on autoformers a bit more. You might also want to reflect upon the various McIntosh solid state amplifiers which use autoformers at their outputs. Which by presenting the output stages with the same load impedance when a 2 ohm speaker is connected to the 2 ohm tap as when a 4 ohm speaker is connected to the 4 ohm tap as when an 8 ohm speaker is connected to the 8 ohm tap, enable those amplifiers to have identical power ratings into 2, 4, and 8 ohms. Regards, -- Al |
Post removed |
Xonex77, as someone with multiple degrees in electrical engineering and
multiple decades of experience designing and managing design of analog
and digital circuits for advanced defense electronics, I can assure you
that I am well aware that placing an impedance in parallel with some
other impedance (of similar type, i.e., not an L in parallel with a C) results in the total impedance being less than either of
the two individual impedances, at a given frequency. The point, though, is that you and Realdeal appear to be envisioning autoformers as behaving as if they were inductors, and they are not inductors. While autoformers (as well as transformers) possess some degree of parasitic (undesired) inductance (and also resistance), they are different animals. And as I indicated, an autoformer can transform voltages and impedances just as a transformer can. See the section in this Wikipedia writeup on the equivalent circuit of a real-world transformer, and this Wikipedia writeup on autoformers. Some brief excerpts from the latter writeup: ... The voltage and current ratio of autotransformers can be formulated the same as other two-winding transformers.... As in a two-winding transformer, the ratio of secondary to primary voltages is equal to the ratio of the number of turns of the winding they connect to.... In audio applications, tapped autotransformers are used to adapt speakers to constant-voltage audio distribution systems, and FOR IMPEDANCE MATCHING [emphasis added] such as between a low-impedance microphone and a high-impedance amplifier input.Surely you don’t deny that a transformer can transform impedances (in proportion to the square of the turns ratio)? Well, an autoformer ("auto-transformer") can also. Regards, -- Al |
Upon re-reading my previous post, to be more precise it occurs to me that I should re-word the second paragraph as follows: The point, though, is that you and Realdeal appear to be envisioning (incorrectly) that autoformers behave as if they are inductors, and nothing more. But while autoformers operate based on inductive principles, they behave differently than inductors, assuming that a load is present. Just as the primary winding of a two-winding transformer behaves differently than an inductor, assuming that a load is present. And as I indicated, an autoformer can transform voltages and impedances just as a transformer can. Regards, -- Al |
I had a pair of Fourier Panthere monoblocks with 8 6C33C Russian military triodes each that powered a pair of Essence Super Gem and later Wilson Sophia speakers through an autoformer. When things were right, the sound was glorious. Not the lean, hyper-detailed, flat-soundstage, micro-image sound you hear so often, but big, transparent, harmonically-rich sound that washed over you and left you mesmerized. The problem was: you never knew what you would get when you turned these beasts on and watched the lights in the house dim as the amps doubled as space heaters. Sometimes everything went right and on others bass authority seemed light and a check of the amps indicated one or more blown tube fuses. Sometimes in the middle of the music something seemed askew and I noticed one channel had popped its little red circuit breaker. After I took the amp apart and cleaned and tensioned the tube sockets, things seemed more stable, but finally I realized that I wanted to escape the world's problems by listening to music, not add to them with a problematic amp. Perhaps the newer OTL designs are more stable, such as Atma-Sphere, but with older designs listening often became a project. Perhaps this is why almost every manufacturer of these designs went out of business. |