I own both. the VR when set up properly will throw a huge soundstage and sounds good off axis and whether you sit down or stand up. The Thiel sounds more musical to me, is harder to drive, prefers solid state and the sound changes when you stand up. Both are good speakers and great value at the current used prices. The 3.5's wound up in my home theatre because I couldn't bear to sell them. Another good choice IMO would be Vandersteen 2ce signature. Good luck
