Thiel 2.4 VS 3.6


I cannot decide between the Thiel 2.4 and 3.6 and welcome opinions and suggestions. I currently own a pair of Martin Logan Odysseys which I love BUT they do not work well in my new room environment in my new home. I listened to the Thiel 2.4's at CES and though they are not planar speakers they had that "electrostatic fast reacting type sound". Do the 3.6's have that same 2.4 type sound with a more robust low end or is the 3.6 a compromise due to it's older technology? Any comments or experiences are welcomed and appreciated. I currently own a Mark Levinson No. 331 or a Theta Dreadnaught II to drive them with.

I have a decent sized listening room but is has some challenges. My AV nook forces me to place my left main speaker within 6 inches of the left side wall and my right main speaker has to sit between the right side of my nook and my fireplace (basically in the middle of the room 7 feet from the left main speaker) The room is about 20 feet wide and 25 feet deep (with my dining room sharing the same space)
sodapop

Showing 1 response by sbank

I recently heard the 2.4s at a Thiel dealer, well set up in a large treated room w/top notch Audio Research gear. To me, it was a major disappointment. To my ears, it honked in the mids, and was limited in dynamics. I don't remember the 2.3 striking me that way when I heard them.
The dealer asserted that it does outperform the 3.6 in the mids/highs, but that the 3.6 will still give deeper, lower bass, given the larger cabinet, & different drivers. He implied that the 3.6 should be replaced by a 3.7 somewhere in the next year or two, which makes sense given the history of their other model changes.
When I owned 3.6s, a number of years ago, I didn't think that they conveyed the speed of electrostatics. Nor do I think the 2.4s do that.
If you loved the Odysseys in your old room, I'd first try to play with placement and room treatment before throwing in the towel. At a minimum try toeing in the left speaker to minimize side wall reflections. If you didn't love the Odysseys in the old room, I'd vote for 2.4s over 3.6s, but would really recommend auditioning other speakers that better provide the "speedy sound" you're after. Keep us posted...
Spencer