First of all, there aint no way Im gonna sound as eloquent as the original poster or some of those after. I really do enjoy the new Lips album, and think of it as one of the top 2 or 3 of 2002. I have not given considerable listens to any of the stuff before Yoshimi, so I will hold back any opnions I have formed of that stuff.
But as for Yoshimi, I think it is simply good pop music. Well written, a nice theme throughout, intelligent and heartfelt words and just plain nice to listen to.
I do however have a few questions about some fo your comments. you said "Pearl Jam the comforts of conventional arena-rock (oops, better make that 'alt-rock' nowadays) career-mongering". I may have misunderstood the statement, and while I am far from being a Pearl Jam fan, I think they detested fame and did all they could to get away from it.
And for Sonic Youth, while I am once again not too much of a fan, their recent release Murray Street was a rather good record.
And while I do enjoy the Lips, I would argue that Wilco are currently making the best rock music in the world. They have not been around for 15 years, however if you include Uncle Tupelo, they have been around close to it. They have also continually bettered themselves and put out better music with each passing CD. Summerteeth was a landmark album that followed up Being There, which was an album littered with fantastic gems amongst seminal songwriting. But Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is an album on par with Pet Sounds, or What's going on? or the joshua tree.
Of course, what do I know?
Justin
But as for Yoshimi, I think it is simply good pop music. Well written, a nice theme throughout, intelligent and heartfelt words and just plain nice to listen to.
I do however have a few questions about some fo your comments. you said "Pearl Jam the comforts of conventional arena-rock (oops, better make that 'alt-rock' nowadays) career-mongering". I may have misunderstood the statement, and while I am far from being a Pearl Jam fan, I think they detested fame and did all they could to get away from it.
And for Sonic Youth, while I am once again not too much of a fan, their recent release Murray Street was a rather good record.
And while I do enjoy the Lips, I would argue that Wilco are currently making the best rock music in the world. They have not been around for 15 years, however if you include Uncle Tupelo, they have been around close to it. They have also continually bettered themselves and put out better music with each passing CD. Summerteeth was a landmark album that followed up Being There, which was an album littered with fantastic gems amongst seminal songwriting. But Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is an album on par with Pet Sounds, or What's going on? or the joshua tree.
Of course, what do I know?
Justin