Tekton vs. Salk Sound?


Hi,

I currently own a pair of Salk Song3s. I am looking for something much more and have a budget of $10K-$15K. My main use is 50/50 of HT and music.

I prefer to not use a sub at all, because I live in a shared townhouse. This is a huge requirement for me. I feel that a separate sub just has way too much bottom end and ends up shaking down the entire building and pissing off the neighbors. My current Song3s go down to 30Hz, but obviously nowhere near the feel/loudness of a separate sub.

I heard a lot about Tekton, but never heard them. Does anyone here have experience with both? I have always remained loyal to Salk, but as I continue to upgrade, I do not want to be ignorant to better brands and be boxed into only Salk.

I always thought that I get a lot more speaker for the money with Salk compared to other brands. Now that I have a larger budget, I want to challenge that assumption.

What else should I be looking at for $10K-$15K price range?

Anyone have experience with Salk vs Tekton that could weight in?

My current amp is a Mcintosh MC207 with Anthem AVM60. I also have a separate MAC6700 for music only.

Thanks in advance and look forward to others' thoughts.
dhanks

Showing 2 responses by dep14

@mapman 

Agree.  I think John is one of the better guys in the business, honest and they have good support.  Jim Salk is the same (and I am sure there are others).

Both are very honest about their speakers etc.
Tekton - what I think of Tekton is a modern day Klipsch in many ways, though with poorer customer service even though it’s a smaller company.

Tekton’s so some things pretty well, they play loud, relatively cleanly. They are relatively dynamic, and can have a bit of a "wow" factor when you first hear them. They are not bad, though they are not the absolute world beaters some here would lead you to believe. If you like what they do, they are fine. What I found is that much like Klipsch used to be - as you move "up" the line in price (and drivers), you get MORE of the same. Having heard much of Eric’s line-up - the Double Impact is the sweet spot. 3k or so, and they do a number of things well, they can play loud etc. IMO a very good party speaker, and is not limited to that.  (but would make a great party speaker also as they can play loud and clean and it's not like it's a spectacular cabinet you might get dinged up). 

As you move up from there, you just a lot more of the same. The law of diminishing returns with Tekton, in my opinion is very very steep. Over the course of a month I had the chance to hear the D.I. The D.I.S.E., the monitors, and the Ulf’s.

The D.I. and D.I.S.E. were in the same room, house, system and music played. It was very, very, hard to tell the difference in the two. The D.I. I thought for a 3k speaker - damn, it does a lot pretty well and is pretty fun. The D.I.S.E. - I felt the same way, and felt there is no way it is more than even 5% better.

I heard the ULF’s at a known reviewers house the same day. Again, very, very similar to the D.I. Which makes sense. But there was absolutely, positively no way in my mind even taking into account that there is ALWAYS a law of diminishing returns, that it was worth 4x more, not even 2x more than the D.I.

I kicked around a set of the Double Impacts because I did feel for 3k they offered a lot, but they also missed a lot. Moving up the line didn’t get me improvements, it got me more.

OHM for instance actually is honest about this in their line-up. Say what you will about OHM, John is very honest. His speakers sound the same, but as you move up the line you get more. Pick the room size and your speaker size (though I think they point you one size too small, but I like bass).

With Tekton the cabinets and finish are average at best, and you can do your own research on customer service, just know that by in large - Eric is never wrong, and it’s never his fault. You don’t have to take my word for it, just search the internet. I wouldn’t say don’t buy Tekton at all, but I would say if you go above the DI’s just know what you are getting into and know the drawbacks. If I were still in college, I absolutely would look for a pair of used Double Impacts. Fun speaker, good value, not overly refined and at that point in my life I wasn’t looking for that.

So, you get a lot of good with the bad with Tekton.

Salk - Exquisite cabinets, top notch drivers, and phenomenal customer service. Downsides might be that right now the SS 9.5 is his top speaker and for some they won’t deliver the absolute bottom end bass and ability to move air that bigger speakers and drivers might deliver. Jim’s speakers sound great, but speaker sound is truly in the ear of the beholder. What I might think sounds great, you might think doesn’t sound very good.

I can tell you with Salk there are clear differences in the line-up, and I can absolutely point to getting more for your money than the big companies by simply looking at the quality of the cabinets and drivers used.

That’s what does amuse me at times about all of this. We all value different qualities in sound reproduction, all listen at different volumes, and have different rooms.