sub 500 turn table

hi , i'd like some input on a entry level turntable, i've narrowed it down to a new MusicHall mm5($420) or Nad 533($348) but open for suggestions....
i've bought many items used off 'gon and ebay but i'm a lil worried about a non original boxed purchase of a tt(fed-ex gorilla's)

currently i'm running:
arc ls-3
2 parasound 1200II's bi.
rega planet
meadowlark kestrel's (hr)
audioquest ic's,cables
pro-ject phono box just purchased new off ebay for $40
any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.