Stereophile review of the McCormack UDP-1


Has anyone read the January 2005 issue of Stereophiles review of the McCormack UDP-1 universal Player?
While the reviewer found that it sounded excellent, the measurements on it were horrible!
John Atkinson said that it had relatively high noise levels, and that SACD and DVD-Audio playback had no greater resolution than regular CD!
What gives here?
daltonlanny

Showing 1 response by adasilva

I've listened to the McCormack at a dealer (using both Classe and Krell amps/pre). I'd originally gone to the dealer looking to upgrade my Classe CDP to a Cary 303-200. While I was listening to the Cary CDP the dealer dropped the McCormack on top of the Cary connected the wires to a another input and left the room.

This dealer had always told me I was better to get a dedicated CD only player and DVD player. After demoing for an hour (CDs only) I'm not sure that I like the McCormack better than the Cary303-200 but it was close enough.

The thought of upgrading my CDP to a $3000+ CD-only player is now gone with the McCormark UDP at $2995(dealer price). Although I didn't take the plung, for the first time I felt that CD-only players are not in my future...