Soliloquy 5.3 vs. ProAc 1.5

If rock makes up a large part of your listening, I wouldn't suggest either of these speakers. For acoustic and light jazz, yes. I suggest you look into the Meadowlark Shearwater Hot Rods. They are sweet sounding, detailed and great with dynamic music, when needed. Classe amps are great with the Shearwaters, also Plinius. Try before you buy!

Acssavings, It is surprising to me that you describe the Shearwaters that way, flat and lacking dynamics. I truely think they are just the opposite. Who knows? Personal taste? Setup? Bad day? I think there are so many variables, and that is why it is hard to put together a system that we can be happy with. I have bought a number of pieces that I auditioned and liked, only to find they weren't for me after extended listening. Imagine how hard it is to find enjojment in equiptment based on other's advice. More proof, when it's time to buy, listen for yourself!