Solid State vs. Tubes - What if Transistors came first?


What do you guys think?

If transistors came first, and then decades later tubes were invented, would we have any tube amps we would call high end?

Wouldn’t they all fail to reach the height of performance and transparency set by transistor amps?

Best,

E

P.S. I love Conrad Johnson. I'm just wondering how  much of our arguments have to do with timing. 
erik_squires

Showing 50 responses by maritime51

Tubes, in my view, are a waste of time and money, but it is a hobby....
What a fatuous question. Why do people drive old cars?  Play records?  Tape decks?
I grew up with tubes. Pure dee crap. In fact, I was in school with one of De Forest’s grandsons, for what that’s worth. 👀💩🚽


"As a growing competitor to the tube amplifier comes now the Bell Laboratories’ transistor, a three-electrode germanium crystal of amazing amplification power, of wheat-grain size and low cost. Yet its frequency limitations, a few hundred kilocycles, and its strict power limitations will never permit its general replacement of the Audion amplifier." – 1952
Wax cylinders, that’s the ticket, and when combined with acoustic playback, ne plus ultra!  💩
Sometimes you are funny. I used Collins radios for years. They went solid state long before that time. 
I think I earlier mentioned I was in school with one of Lee Deforest’s grandsons. He often quoted the old man’s last words: “Tubes suck.”  ⚰️
Who am I to argue with “de forest.”

tubes suck.  🧟‍♂️🚽🃏
Uh, in Hades, his punishment is to stand in the lake of boiling blood, listening to a tube amp, err, imp.  
He shall learn the maxim, “As you are now, I once was. As I am now, so shall you be.”
@Dave. I’m no misanthrope. I had a very complete secondary school education, followed by university, and professional school, then a higher degree. 
Ex turpi causa non oritur actio.  -Lee Deforest. (Tubes suck, a learned treatise)
How about it.

What if the best part of Geof hadn’t run down the sheet? 🙀. -Lee Deforest
And, the cars would be larger. 

What if Lee Harvey couldn’t hit a barn at 100 yards...what if Lee Deforest had gone straight to the transistor....😁
Ha, ha, it’s true, my hearing is shot, but at least I didn’t get my DNA strained through a sheet. And, I do love peaches and hamburgers. 👍
Ad hominems are weapons of the ignorant. The irony of the use of ad hominems is only exceeded by the lack of skill in application. 
“It’s so charming when one troll has another troll’s back.“

Yes, isn’t it. 👀🃏🤡