room treatment, where do you start?


an analysis of the room would seem to be the place to start, right? what tools do you need, what do you do first? Buy, or can better tools be rented?; One presumably wouldn't need to use such tools again until you move or change speakers. Do you first calculate the two fundamental room modes mathematically and buy devices to attenuate those? I last tried electronic eq in the 80's, which introduced an undesirable reduction in clarity (tone controls were still popular, then); are analogue eg units as useful as one would expect, substantially better than they once were (I am not interested in taking an analogue signal from LP through an a/d to d/a conversion). I am starting from scratch, understand tuning by ear will be required, want a more or less scientific, targeted approach. It's a rented apartment, so it's impractical to invest in experts, e.g. Rives.
lloydc

Showing 4 responses by rrog

I recommend getting advice from someone other than the guy selling the room treatment.
You start by determining whether or not you need room
treatment.

This question comes up on a regular basis. Many folks avoid responding and I should too since I'm beginning to sound like a broken record even to myself.

There is no guarantee room treatment will improve the sound of your system. Some of the best systems I have heard were in rooms with no room treatment at all.
Elizabeth, It sounds like you have a nice arrangement. Are you using long speaker wire or long interconnect?
Edge22, I think what Elizabeth is saying is her room treatment consists of furnishing and window treatment and there is nothing wrong with this approach. Even if you use commercial acoustical products furniture and window treatment should be taken into consideration anyway.

As for me, I have used room treatment for over 20 years, but only where it is absolutely necessary. I believe "experts in acoustics" have a tendency to over treat rooms and over treating is as bad as undertreating.