Ripple current Q for amp capacitors


I have a pair of EAD powermaster 1000's in my theater. The older one is at least 25 years old I think, and developed a slight hum I could hear in the theater.  So I popped it open, did a cap inventory and replaced them all. I checked every one of the main amp caps as I pulled them out, and surprisingly they all seemed really good still, within tolerance.

 

But I didn't replace the two large filter caps. I had searched for a 100,000uf CD cap online, clicked on the link to Mouser, and purchase 4 (2 for each amp.. figured I would do both). However when all the caps arrived, I realized in my haste the link was to 10,000uf caps instead.. DOH! So I went back and tried to find the matching caps.. expensive! And to top that off, when I "could" find some (Ebay mainly), the date code was around the year 2000 as well so they were about the same age. Digikey has a lead time to about December.. and also over $200cdn each.

The original spec was a Cornell Dubilier, 100000uf 50v -10%/+75% cap. They do have a 100v version in stock, half the price, and actually shorter than the 50v version.

But my question is this.. when I search online for whether a low or high ripple current is preferable for an audio amp, I get both answers.. low is better because then it filters better, to high being better because that means the cap can handle more ripple and heat. Which is correct?

The 50v version is:

7mOhm ESR @ 120Hz, 29.3 A @ 120Hz, 38.09 @ 10 kHz

the 100v version is:

10.2mOhm ESR @120Hz, 23.4A @120Hz, 24.57A @ 10kHz

I have no idea if these numbers are incredibly close, or meaningfully different.. and which is better?

tester007

Showing 1 response by gs5556

Did replacing the other caps eliminate the slight hum? If so, then the best advice is to leave the big caps alone. If it works, don't fix it.

As far as which of the two caps to use: you'd have to do a little bit of research and see if both versions of the CDE caps were available at the time of the EAD1000 production. If so, then the designers made the choice. 

When I use new large can caps, I hook them up to a bench power supply and run it on 5 volts for an hour then quickly turn up the voltage to the cap's max rated voltage (or the limit of the power supply) and see the if the current rises and drops to zero fairly quickly -- which is what a normal healthy cap does.