Revel Salon 2 versus WP 8

He's probably referring to the press falling all over themselves praising Wilson speakers. At the end of the day, many people, myself included, are of the opinion that Wilson hasn't been SOTA (ever?) for some time now, particularly not with Focal's hand-me-down tweeter showing its age.

As to the revels, while their driver integration is amazing, the praise heaped on them recently is imo excessive; they're great speakers but they surely are not the end all.

No doubt about that, if there was one right product there wouldn't be hundreds of manufacturers; I don't think any serious enthusiast would ever have the delusion that there is a best. The key is that the person is happy with their system.

Why are you trying so hard to defend your purchase and disprove another person's opinion. You guys disagree; leave it at that as it's quite obvious neither of you are about to come over to the other side.

iirc, it's because he's going with the Revel Salon2.

I wouldn't put too much stock into a review from a publication with the credibility problems that one currently has. In any case, it's getting old how every few months (now apparently month to month) they find a new benchmark.

However, your point with regard to the W/P measurements is valid, and I concur.

Nice reply JKalman and thanks for clarifying your comments which were not as simple as originally stated.

Hasn't this thread come to its conclusion anyhow. He chose the Revels over the Wilson; V3 is irrelevant.