Replace CD jewel boxes with archival sleeves?


Hi, folks:

I would like to reduce the volume and weight of my large CD collection by getting rid of the jewel cases. I still play CDs on my main system and want them to be easily accessible. The primary options seem to be paper or plastic sleeves that can be used stand-alone or in a 3-ring binder. I could also use the thin jewel cases, but they would still be heavy and would not show the side content flap on the side of the CD.

I've researched various products. Here are a few products I found:

Univenture polypropelyne jewel pack
http://homepage.mac.com/amurnieks/acmin ... eeves.html

Univenture archival sleeve
http://www.planetdj.com/i--10196

Tyvek window sleeve with flap
http://www.buskerdoo.com/catalog/tyvek- ... ap-33.html
http://www.cddimensions.com/Tyvek-CD-Sl ... YV-WINDOW/

Viewpack XD 2 pocket polypropylene sleeve
http://www.sleevetown.com/multi-disc-cd-sleeves.shtml
http://www.univenture.com/shop/viewpak_ ... sleeve.php

CD binders and sleeves
http://www.sleevetown.com/cd-binders.shtml

- If I use sleeves, one concern is what material to use? They are made in vinyl, polypropelyne, and paper. Buskerdoo recommends paper sleeves for long-term archival, saying that CDs can stick to plastic over time. My experience is that polypropelyne would be better (and less smelly) than vinyl. Not sure if it is better than paper.
http://www.buskerdoo.com/html/articles/ ... g_CDs.html

- If I use sleeves, I would prefer a dual sleeve - one that holds both the CD and the paper insert (CD cover sheet). I suppose I could use single CD sleeves and tape the cover sheets to the sleeves.

What have others done? Recommendations?

Cheers,

Fred
fred971

Showing 2 responses by fred971

Hey, folks, thanks for your comments. Is there any formal or empirical research on the various kinds of sleeves: paper, vinyl, polyethylene, polyurethane? Any experience after using them for 10 years or so? My highest priority is to preserve the CDs.

Thanks,

Fred
Folks, as the originator of this thread, here is the solution I went with to replace my CD jewel boxes. After a lot of research and obtaining product samples, I went with Jazzloft CD sleeves. http://www.jazzloft.com . The CDs can be inserted with the data side against the CD's paper insert, or against the plastic sleeve. I discussed it with them and they say that placing the data side against the paper insert will not harm the CD, so I am doing that. An advantage of these sleeves is that the CD paper insert side title (the title strip that shows on the edge of the jewell box) wraps around inside the sleeve. If you stack CDs loosely together, this title is still somewhat visible, making it easier to identify your CDs.

Another good product is the Univenture CD sleeve (they have several styles). http://www.univenture.com . The Univenture sleeves have an orange peel surface. I prefer the smooth Jazzloft surface - less reflection for me.

One disadvantage with plastic sleeves is that they are a little slippery, so you can't stack CDs vertically more than about 4" - like you might do if you grab a handful of CDs and place them on a table to look through. But that's a small price to pay for eliminating jewell boxes.

To replace DVD jewel boxes, I went with Discsox sleeves. http://www.discsox.com or http://www.mmdesign.com . These sleeves hold all of the paper inserts without cutting or folding. They have Bluray versions, too.

Cheers,

Fred