I just purchased a REL S/510. It replaces a 20 year old Velodyne HT sub. At first I was going to purchase the HT/1510. My local audio guy convinced me to get the S/510 instead. He knows my system inside/out and more importantly, the characteristics of my 14 x 12 listening room.
My listening experience is 80% music and 20% tv and movies. My main speakers are B&W 804s. The S/510 works seamlessly with all my source components: Denon DCD A110 SACD/CD player, innuos Zenith mk3 streamer + innuos Phoenix USB, and Bricasti M3 DAC, Modwright Oppo 105, and EAT C-Sharp turntable/Sutherland phono pre amp.
Rock, jazz, classical, electronic, etc., all sound fantastic to my ears. My audio guy is a graduate of the Berklee College of Music, and he knows how live music should sound. I consider myself a lucky guy because he has my system tuned perfectly, IMO.
If you are more of a movie guy, you may be better served with the HT/1510. The S/510 does not produce slamming bass that will make your teeth chatter. It is smoothly integrated with my B&W 804s, and that combination brings tight/punchy/fast/full bass to the music I listen to.
Good luck!