2. speakers
  3. 1306444766

Piega P-10 vs Montana ESP 2

Hi Guys,

The Piega is old and I want to find a replacement. The speaker I am interested is Montana ESP 2. For those who had experiences with both speakers, please let me know that it would be an upgrade or just similar.

Room: 18 x 25 x 12
Source: Resolution CD-55
Pre-Amplifier: Counterpoint SA-11
Amplifier: Counterpoint NP-100 monoblocks (300W @ 8ohm)
Music: Classical & large orchestra

Of course, I am open to other speaker suggestion.

Thanks!

Tai
yu11375
4 responses Add your response
shakeydeal
979 posts
 
BTW, it is the EPS-2.

I have owned both and I can tell you the Montana is NOT an upgrade from the Piega. Far from it. You will not have an easy time replacing the Piegas. I tried to do it with Wilson Sophias and sold the Wilsons in less than a month. I did eventually move to GMA Continuum C3s which are better, but not by a country mile...

Shakey
yu11375 OP
137 posts
 
Hi Shakey,

Thanks for your response. Yes, it is EPS-2.

What are the attributes of EPS-2 and Sophias inferior to P-10?

Tai
shakeydeal
979 posts
 
The Piegas to my ears are more resolving and less boxy than the Montanas. The Sophias midrange was not as detailed as the rest of the spectrum. The Piega had a more involving sound than either.

Shakey
yu11375 OP
137 posts
 
Thanks, Shakey. That's very helpful.

This morning I contacted the local dealer who presented PIEGA in the past for help. They are going to ask PIEGA in Switzerland to see what upgrade would be available (replacing drivers and/or crossover).

Tai
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
Scansonic Scansonic MB6B
80x80
Meridian DSP7200
80x80
Paradigm Persona 5F