Phono Stage - The great analog tragedy


In the world of analog playback, there is an interesting observation. There has been tremendous innovation in the field of 
Turntable - Direct, Idler, Belt
Cartridge - MM, MC, MI
Tonearm - Gimbal, Unipivot, Linear Tracking

For all of the above designs we find some of the best reference components designed in the 50s, 60s, 70s and 80s. Most of the modern products are inspired from these extraordinary products of the past. But when it comes to phono stage, there is hardly any "reference component" from that era. They just standardized RIAA curve for sanity and left it. Manufacturers made large preamps and amps and allocated a puny 5% space for a small phono circuit even in their reference models, like a necessary evil. They didn’t bother about making it better. 

The result? It came down to the modern designers post 2000 after vinyl resurgence to come up with serious phono stages for high end systems. Unfortunately they don’t have any past reference grade designs to copy or get inspired from. Effectively, just like DACs, reference phono stages is also an evolving concept, and we don’t have too many choices when we want a really good one which is high-res and natural sounding. Very few in the world have figured out a proper high end design so far. And most of the decent ones have been designed in the past couple of decades. The best of the breed are probably yet to come.  

It is a tragedy that our legendary audio engineers from the golden era didn’t focus on the most sensitive and impactful component, "the phono stage"

pani

Showing 5 responses by larryi

It probably is the case that no one back then even thought of a phono stage as a separate component; that would explain the dearth of examples.  Back then, no one thought of power cords as discrete components either.  Also, the popularity of low output cartridges is a modern thing; their would have been no need for phono stages back then to work with such low output.

Yes, I agree that it is interesting that there were no stand alone phonostages back in the 1950's and 1960's, but, that was just not a thing.  All gear had to have a phono section so not many companies chose to unbundle the phono stage.  Separates, except for tuners was not a thing.  Tuners were such complicated devices I can see why some chose to make high end separates for tuners.  

It would be interesting to see how good is the phono section of some classic preamplifiers.   

Strain gauge cartridge output is dependent on the amplitude of the movement of the stylus while most other cartridges have output dependent of the velocity of the stylus movement.  Amplitude sensitive cartridges can sort of get away with no equalization--the frequency response curve will not be perfect, but it is, arguably good enough.  SoundSmith originally went with no equalization with their cartridge, but relented when the market complained about this approach.

High end phono is no different than anything else in audio--any given model will be liked by some and disliked by others.  I have not gone on any sort of careful exploration of the subject, nor have I made that many direct comparisons in my own system or systems that I know well enough to judge the sound.  I tend to like tube phono stages and of current brands; I like those made by Audio Note (uk) and Lector (italian).  Of the other brands that I am less familiar with, I liked what I hard from Zanden and Doshi.  The big disappointment to me was the Boulder which sounded too dry and analytical for my taste. 

How I arrived at the one in my own system is an embarrassment.  I bought it without hearing it from a friend who was the US distributor for the brand.  He had to sell the one he used for audio shows because the power supply unit sustained some cosmetic damage so he sold it to me for a small fraction of the retail price.  The offer was too tempting to pass up.  I got lucky--I like how it sounds.

EAR 912 is a good call for an example of something extraordinary.  Someone above mentioned the Mares Connoisseur.  I have not heard it, but I heard the version Lyra licensed and built and it sounded great—very dynamic and vivid sounding.  The Lyra Connoisseur is one of the few solid state preces I would welcome in my system.