FWIW, I use a Coincident I/C from my Scoutmaster to my phonostage (which is now a Joule Electra OPS; formerly ARC SP8). While I do not always agree with Arthur Salvatore, here is what he says about Coincidents for this use:
http://www.high-endaudio.com/RC-IC-Phono.html
I've also tried the Cardas Neutral Reference, but like the Coincident slightly better. The Coincident just seems a bit "cleaner" with a bit better resolution and low level detail.
I have also used a one meter VPI phono cable with good results, but I need a slightly longer cable for my current configuration.
I've also tried several others between the TT and phonostage, but IMHO, they were not "at home" in this placement. In the end though, you are doing the right thing to audition as many as you can to see what YOU like.
Good Luck
http://www.high-endaudio.com/RC-IC-Phono.html
I've also tried the Cardas Neutral Reference, but like the Coincident slightly better. The Coincident just seems a bit "cleaner" with a bit better resolution and low level detail.
I have also used a one meter VPI phono cable with good results, but I need a slightly longer cable for my current configuration.
I've also tried several others between the TT and phonostage, but IMHO, they were not "at home" in this placement. In the end though, you are doing the right thing to audition as many as you can to see what YOU like.
Good Luck