Now I get it...

LOL thanks @

You’re right, and I still play (and enjoy) the “terrible” ones.  Just never understood how much better a truly good recording can sound.  The SQ gap between good and poor seems much larger now (to my ears).    

Thank you everyone!  Glad I’m not alone in the rabbit hole.

Guys, I appreciate your thoughtful responses.  I think in my original post I should have flipped the narrative to say that I am amazed about just how awesome some of my records sound.  With my new set-up I am astounded about how some of my albums just make me go "Holy S***!"  While the others, most often the reissue 180 gram "audiophile pressings", are enjoyable but sound less alive.  There are exceptions to that rule, of course, but I think you all understand.  In other words, I now finally get the value of consideration paid in searching out really good vinyl.  Steve Hoffman forums have become my friend when looking for these reviews. YMMV.  Am I having fun?  Heck yes! 

Hi @millercarbon, funny you should bring that up!  I just ordered my first LP from Better-Records, an early release White Hot Stamper of Black Sabbath's self-titled debut.  I am so excited to hear it, especially after your comments above.  Will report back once received (should be here next week). 

@mammothguy54, my copy of SRV's In Step from Analogue Productions is on the way!

To everyone else who has been responding to this post... THANK YOU!  I have thoroughly enjoyed your insights.