New Mercury Living Presence Mastering


Eloquence, the Australian label has recently released two recorded sets of Paul Paray conducting the Detroit Symphony from the original Mercury Living Presence catalog.
These extensive new sets have been remastered by Thomas Fine, son of the original producer Robert Fine. After listening for a while, I discovered to my dismay that he has emasculated the original Mercury sound to sound like run of the mill current commercial CD recordings.
No less of an authority than Henry Fogel in a review misguidedly calls them “excellent restorations,” presuming that they NEEDED restoration.
These are classic recordings that were incredible sounding when first released on LP and subsequently on CD transfers by Philips.
It’s a travesty! All the magic is gone. On a high resolution set the sound is comparatively lifeless and homogenized. Evidently Thomas thought he was “fixing” the sound to appeal to mid-fi consumers.
What a missed opportunity!

128x128rvpiano

Showing 2 responses by melm

This was discussed extensively on another board at the time of release. The consensus IIRC is that they are indistinguishable from the original CD releases supervised by Thomas’ mother. As such it was considered a disappointment. However, there may be some new material not released on CD originally

The 'restoration" spoken of is likely the restoration of the original analog tapes.  Mercury, unlike most other companies, did not prepare a master tape for the disk cutting and later for the CD transformation (though the Golden Imports did).  They always used the original session tapes.  These tapes were handled, and perhaps mishandled repeatedly and were said to need a great deal of care to make them usable for yet another series.  Apparently they needed a good bit or cleaning off of old glue and re-taping.

Notwithstanding, I think I have a high resolution system and I think the sound of these old Mercuries is fine, though some are much better than others. That was also true on the original CDs, and on the LPs.

In any event they are all up on Qobuz so you can make up your own mind.

@rvpiano 

You might want to look here and here for openers

For an audiophile board discussing classical music, you're in the wrong place.