Interesting predicament! Fortunately, you have some great options. Here are recommendations from speakers I’ve experienced:
Wolf Von Langa Serendipity+: I recently heard these at Gestalt Audio and they are phenomenal speakers. Definitely worth checking out.
Acora Acoustics: outstanding speakers, I’ve been repeatedly impressed by Acoras and they look terrific.
Morel Sopran: These good looking narrow floor standers blew me away at a show last year. Superb speakers at an exceptional price
Joseph Audio: I’ve heard numerous Joseph speakers and have always been impressed. A safe bet if you can find a great used pair.
PS Audio FR5: I’ve heard the bigger FR models at a friends and they were terrific, better than I expected.
Salk Sound BePure 1: an absolute giant killer with the terrific SB beryllium tweeter and the incomparable Purifi woofer. Unfortunately, Salk Sound is no longer in business.
Boressen X1 or X3: I haven’t heard the X1 but I loved the X3 when I heard it at a show. Coming off Maggie’s, you may like their unique ribbon tweeter. However, they can be a bit sterile and fussy.
Alta Alyssa: Mike Levy makes great speakers with gorgeous cabinetry. Definitely worth considering.
MBL 126: a very special and unique speaker that generates a holographic stage unlike almost any other speaker. Unfortunately, MBL is in bankruptcy and their fate is in question.
Good luck in your journey!