Need Detail/ Resolution with Impact and Weak Bass


Sounds weird right? Need some speakers for the bedroom. Having tried Electrostatic (Martin Logan) I liked the detail and spaciousness but hated that you got no impact from a rimshot, no "glistening" from high-hats and dynamic range seemed compressed. Plus, there was too much bass! The room is configured somehow to totally reinforce the bass so bass-shy speakers are actually preferred, as the bass is naturally augmented. I have a lot of amplifiers, so the options are Counterpoint SA-220 (220 watts, hybrid), Adcom GFA-555 II (200 watts solid state), or a BAT VK-200 (100 watts solid state). I don't really need it to play LOUD, meaning the music goes right through you, its the bedroom after all, but need to play with good dynamic contrasts knowing that the bass will be reinforced. The speakers will face the awesome leather chair, for relaxed listening and then need to be turned 90 degrees to face the bed because my timer will kick in at 7:30 am and activate the power conditioner which turns on the amps to wake me up, so we can't have anything to unmanageably large and unweildy. Am thinking Merlin VSM's or B&W Nautilus bookshelf, but have not heard either. Don't like a bookshelf with stands less than 28" because they need to shoot over the bedframe. Sorry to gross everyone out with the bedroom stories (hey I'm not badlooking), but I know you all have great recommendations so lets hear them.
south_park

Showing 1 response by audiokinesis

Greetings South Park,

First, let me tell you what I think might be happening with the Martin Logans in your room.

Sound propagates differently from a line source than from a point source, and with the hybrid Martins the panels act as a line source, and the woofers as a point source. Sound pressure level literally falls off more slowly with distance from a line source than from a point source. Theoretically, sound pressure level falls off linearly with distance from a line source, and with the square of distance from a point source. Under anechoic conditions, if a line source and a point source are both putting out 90 dB at one meter, then back at 10 meters the line source will be doing 80 dB but the point source will only be doing 70 dB!

What this means is, when a designer seeks to combine a line source panel with a point source woofer, he has to voice the speaker for the general room size he expects the speaker to be used in (or else provide the customer with level controls). If your Martin Logans were in too small a room, the bass level would not have fallen off as much as the designer intended, and the speakers would be bass-heavy.

Now, possibly your room does over-emphasize the bass. If so, it is doing this through bass standing wave modes. You might consider the Gradient Revolution, which uses a rather unique dipole bass loading configuration. For a given on-axis sound pressure level, a dipole bass system will put 5 dB less energy into the room's resonant modes. That means the bass notes will decay more quickly and sound more natural. The Revolution excels at producing very natural-sounding bass in less than ideal rooms.

E-mail me if you'd like a more in-depth discussion. I'll be on the road a lot this week, but will try to check my e-mail a few times. Or you can call me at (504) 866-1730 - that should forward you to my cell phone.

Best wishes,

Duke