2. amps-preamps
  3. 1162271869

musical fidelity a5 or simaudio i5.3

i need amp with home theater bypass and have listended to these two. this is for a room that is 20x19x8 with lots of windows and hardwood floors with rug and paired with Dali ikon 7 and a rel sub to be determined. i like them both and found the simaudio to be more detailed but like the $500.difference in price to the A5. i listen to classic rock,electronic,some blues and jazz and at night like to listen at low levels. what might be a better fit for this time of room and music?
Ag insider logo xs@2xneveo
ds5800
4 posts
 
Both amps are good...the Musical Fidelity is made in China, so it is not really British (although British designed), and the Simaudio is made in Canada. The Sim has more speed and a much more tight and powerful bottom end despite its lower power. It is also more neutral and revealing. The MF is a bit warmer and "syrupy", in my opinion. It depends on the sound you are looking for and your speakers too. Plus you get a 10 year warranty with the Sim which is really neat.
bwright
14 posts
 
I have listened to them both, but the Simaudio I heard was the I-5 LE.
That said, to me, the Simaudio sounded better overall - the A5 seemed detailed, but a bit light in presentation without much depth on the bass side - a slightly flat sound. The Simaudio has better flavor/bass depth and yet still highly detailed. It was my close second choice in a recent integrated search.
However, after listening to all available options, I ended up with a Cayin A-88T with 6550s. Never thought I'd end up with a tube amp - the thing sounds amazing. I thought it was a far sight better than most everything I heard...
stevecham
3,340 posts
 
The A5 is made in Taiwan.
More to discover