More watts or better power ?


Hello, I am currently running a PS Audio BHK Preamp, which has a tube input stage, to a Pass Labs XA25, Class A (50watts at 4 ohms) power Amp, into a pair of Sonus Faber Minima Amator II bookshelf speakers. My system sounds very good, and at 4ohms, I have 50 watts of power to my speakers, which is on the lower end of their rating.

What would be a better investment (most bang for the buck) into the system? Replace the XA25 with a higher watt amp (PS Audio BHK 250?), or spend the same money on a power conditioner (PS Audio Power Plant II?) Or upgrade the Minima Amator (which are sounding very good) to another set of speakers.

The system is in my bedroom, I have a very small house, hence the smaller Sonus Faber Speakers. I have beenplaying around with an SVS micro sub as well.

Other system parts, Clear Audio Concept/ Concept MC, Pass Labs XP15, Little Green Roon Server, Schitt Yiggi, and a Luxman MQ 88 Tube amp in rotation.

Appreciate your input
Mark O





marktheshark

Showing 1 response by larryi

The very best sounding amps I've heard are all low in output.  But, these amps are not appropriate for many speakers and in situations where high volume is a requirement and/or the room is extremely large.  So there is a minimum amount of power that is needed, and that minimum is situational.  

It is hard to say whether the 50 watts you have is sufficient.  All else being equal, more power will at least afford you more headroom for the brief peaks when playing very loudly.  That may or may not be a sufficient basis to upgrade to higher power.  But, often there is a sonic price to more power.  I once heard a comparison between a 50 watt Rowland amp and a very similar Rowland amp that was much more powerful.  I actually preferred the sound of the lower powered amp, and the speakers used in the comparison where supposedly a power/current hog.  I don't know why this was the case--it could be that using a larger number of output transistors adversely affects the sound, it could be that some transistor amps don't sound as good when they are just loafing at a small fraction of their capability--but this showed me that more is not necessarily better.

All of my current amps are low-powered tube units (6.5 watts/channel being the brawniest), but, I have appropriately efficient speakers and I prize good low-volume performance over ability to shake the room.