Mods - Odds and Sods???


Hello.

As we all know, here on Audiogon, there has been an increasing number of "modded" components being offered. However, I am wondering about the effectiveness of these mods. Are we often paying more money for equipment that has been modded, but not EFFECTIVELY modded?

I think the trap is to assume that just because something has been modded, it has been improved. Wrong, Wrong, WRONG!

I will not get into the details here yet, because I would like to see how others feel about it.

I will say that I have experience with a product that I have seen an advertisement for, modded. I can tell you that the component has a design flaw from the factory SO egregious that my friend who modded one for himself to correct the situation, feels it had to be intentional. Now, I don't believe that, I don't think a manufacturer would "mess up" a product just so it doesn't outshine their more expensive ones. But, the modded product did not address the issue. In fact, the mod they performed costs much more and is FAR less effective than the mod my friend performed(which happens to be free, outside of the labor involved). And, that is the most telling thing. In my opinion, anyone who performs mods without correcting this problem is not someone I would want to give my money to.

And, I ask, are we now to the point that we are willing to shell out more of our hard earned money for products which do not live up to their hype?
trelja

Showing 1 response by trelja

Sean, thanks for your perspective. It is definitely appreciated, coming from someone who has seen this for real. Anyway, you are so right about swapping parts as opposed to actually modifying a component.

In the situation I was alluding to, the component was "modded" in that the coupling caps were upgraded in these amplifiers. However, the number one issue the NEEDED to be corrected in this product was the fact that the power cabling is bundled with a lot of the other wiring in the amp. Sure, it makes for a cleaner presentation, and probably easier manufacturing, but the difference addressing the cable routing inside these amps overshadows a capacitor upgrade by several orders of magnitude.

My friend is a thorough modifier of equipment, as opposed to someone out to pad their bottom line, because he realized that this free tweak was the most effective and critical improvement that he could make. Over the phone, he wouldn't tell me what this "crime" was, as he wanted to surprise me in person. Of course, he also upgraded the coupling caps, as well as the binding posts, input jack, and tubes. When I asked him what kind of performance gains his changes had wrought, he had no idea, as he never listened to the amps stock. In his opinion, there was just no point.

The thing is with the items for auction here, upgrading a part enabled the seller to fetch 75% more for the used item than what it listed for new. Interesting