MHDT Orchid versus MHDT Pagoda..which one is best?...and why?


Interested in feedback as to which one between these two DACs are most preferred and why. They are both stock, except tubes installed are the WE 396A tube and the Orchid has TDA 1541A S2 crown chip upgrade. Although only the Pagoda passes 192kHz, that in itself is not being considered here in this thread...If any of my audio brethren have had the opportunity to experience/compare these two units side by side, please contribute. Speculation, although appreciated, is only a matter of opinion. 
128x128Ag insider logo xs@2xmooncrikit

I'm gong to enter this post on this thread merely to help it rise once again in the lineup and ask if anyone has any new experience to share here, since the thread was last active in August of 2021. (Gee how time flies!)

Any experience to share here? Anyone?

Member Terry London did a review a few years ago where he directly compared the clue, and I believe he found the Pagoda to sound quite a bit better than the Orchid if you run it balanced.  You can find the review with a search but was probably in Stereo Times or Hometheater.com.  Hope this helps.

Just a quick follow-up. I think this comparison between the Orchid and the Pagoda that might be of interest to others.

For the last week I've had the opportunity to listen to a Pagoda (non-balanced version) in my system and compare it to my Orchid.

I find the descriptions available here and elsewhere on the internet to be accurate. Both DACs excel at musicality. The Pagoda provides more detail, but not in an annoying way. 

Here are a couple of attempts at describing what I hear.

Through the Orchid, pianos tend to sound like big Steinways or Bosendorfers. Through the Pagoda they sound like they could be top-of -the-line Yamahas or Baldwins. Which is more accurate? I don't know.

I'd describe the Orchid as more ballsy, funkier. Meatier on the bass, upper bass, lower midrange and midrange.

The Pagoda is a little tighter in the bass and has a lot more resolution in the treble. 

The Orchid has more body, when it comes to the cello.

The Pagoda has more bow sound.

I hope that makes sense.

I could live with either. 

I do think the treble of the Pagoda requires a compatible interconnect. Otherwise the treble can come across a little shrill.

This is my experience in my system. YMMV.