I have also certainly encountered the elitist attitude that seems to be common to McIntosh dealers. Though I must say my encounters with McIntosh labs have only been positive, thier service is impeccable. Nonetheless, this has nothing to with how their products sound. I have also only had positive experiences with people whom I purchased used mac gear from, which is pretty much the only way I can afford to do it.
Now, they have some products that are just special and deliver that magical McIntosh sound. Stereophile has done soem reviews and there are other reviews out there. I think that their new products receive a lot of scrutiny and face a lot of competition, and they should after all at $7,000 + for each piece people should be picky. Upon listening to their old gems like the 275, or the 110 tuner preamp it becomes hard to argue that the prices they command do not provide a tremendous amount of value. They are rock solid and certainly HIFI. I suppose I fall into the category of music lover as well, I would like to forget that I my audio rack exists as I get lost in the emotion of the music. Audiophile seems to be a sport, somtimes, wherein people forget that this is about music. I see little value in paying for and dwelling on the inaudible. This usually ends in a $100,000 system and ten test recordings; totally ridiculous in my opinion.
But this debate about whether or not McIntosh HIFI, is boring, pointless, and beaten to death.
Now, if anyone can offer some specific advice regarding a cabinet refurbish, C28 mods, or their encounters with the C28 against McIntosh's other C2X or C3X preamps I would really like to hear it. Thanks again guys.