Manley Chinook or Allnic H1201

I haven't found a thread on this that isnt a couple years old. Time to upgrade from modded Jolida J9. These are the top two contenders. Anyone compared them directly? I also see that Herron phono stages get thrown into the discussion at this price point. I'm really trying to stay under 2k, which probably means used.

Cart is a Soundsmith Zephyr 2 on a VPI scout.   

Thanks for any input