Magnepans vs Quad 22L's..


Hi Guys, I currently am listeing to Quad 22L's and like them. However I have the urge to try some Maggies. I've read a lot of good things about them. I kind of live off the beaten path so previewing is tough. I'm thinking about MG12's or 1.6's. My main listening is blues with some classic rock and occasional guitar oriented jazz. Any comments on how they compare with the Quad's?
beernut

Showing 1 response by rotary914

Hi:

I feel unqualified to give you an opinion because I have not heard the 22L's or any of Quads "conventional" speakers.
I am only familiar with their 57's and 63's (electrostatic) since I own them.

But - since no one replied you yet - I'll say "something".

There are many "Magnepan Lovers" that are out there that are just as loyal as Quad Lovers (like me).
I will say this - If there were no Quads I would definitely have a pair of Maggies.
They are VERY Outstanding. (the newer ones).

DO NOT buy an older pair because the conductor (on the older ones) can sometimes separate from the film and they will buzz and sound horrible. (It happened to me)
I do not know if the new ones will degrade like that also in 10 or more years - they apparently fixed that problem, but only time will tell.

I'm just "guessing" that the Maggies will be better than any box speaker.
"Better" is subjective because there are people who actually like the sound of "Bose 901's"
There is a very different sound from a planar source and for the things "I" consider important in sound reproduction, nothing comes close to a planar speaker.

Listen to Maggies if you can - if you are near any.

Just curious - how much do 22L's cost?
Is there a reason you are not considering any of the electrostatic Quads?

Steve