Maggie 1.6QR vs 3.6R and Room Size


Hi,
I've recently moved house and my new listening space is 60'x32'.
I'm using a small monitor speaker (QLN Signature Splitfield II's) and they do a fair job in this larger room, but not great, which is understandable given their small dimensions.
I'm looking at Maggies as the probable choice for an upgrade, but I'm leaning toward the 1.6QR due to cost. My budget is around $4, so if I went for the 3.6's I wouldn't have much left for amplification (current amp is a CJ CAV 50 integrated).
So the question is this: will the 1.6's work in this size room, or should I wait and get more cash together for the 3.6's?
What kind of results might I expect with the 1.6....is there a possibility of ribbon problems when playing at spl's high enough to charge this size room?
Also, does anyone have experience of using the 1.6's with 50w tubes like the CJ CAV?...if this is too small, can anyone recommend a good tubed partner for the 1.6.

I do not have the opportunity to audition these speakers, so would have to commit and buy a used pair on AG then hope for the best.

Lastly, I have a pair of Apogee Caliper Signature II's that have some ribbon damage on one speaker...does anyone think it might be better going through the hassle of having these repaired?....how do they perform in a large room and how do they compare against the 1.6QR

So many problems, so many questions!!

Many thanks in advance for input and insight from a knowledgable audiophile.

Rooze
rooze

Showing 1 response by kck

I had 3.6; went straight from MMG and skipped 1.6. In my large-ish room (but nothing compared to yours) it took a good amp putting out 600 w into 4 ohms to get them sounding good. A Parasound 1500 HCA (I forget the power but I think it was close to 300 w into 4) was definitely NOT enough and clipped, blew fuses, and made the panels flap on peaks. I also tried 100W tubed monos and while the sound was heavenly, there just wasn't enough of it.
Not to be a wisenheimer, but if you have a 60x32 room why is cost your concern? Last I checked, real estate is still more than $1/acre. Anyway. Not having heard the 1.6 in my room I couldn't make the comparo for you, but I will say you need very good quality and quantity of amplification with 3.6. Now, some have driven them with less (far less?) power but the verdict on quality is pretty much unanimous. In other words, dig deep. Or in yet other words, get the 1.6 if funds are short and you can sacrifice maybe a little on the quality side.