Mac Mini vs WDTV as a Music Server ??


Has anyone tried both the WDTV Live and the Mac Mini as a music server?

The WDTV is super cheap, simple, and easy to use without requiring
all the "computer admin" efforts of the Mac Mini route.

With a Mac Mini one would use an external USB DAC. With the
Western Digital TV live one would use Toslink to an external DAC.

Has anyone tried both of these out and could discuss the PROS/CONS of
the WDTV vs the Mac Mini? Would the sound quality be better with a
Mac Mini?
tom92602

Showing 1 response by extra_action

I recently switched from the Apple to Tv to a Mac Mini as an HTPC. Prior to the Apple Tv i had tried several proprietary single box solutions; anyone remember Turtle Beach or Roku.
The single box propriotry solutions, and i would lump Boxee into this were for lack of a better word disasters. SOftware that had not been properly tested, hardware incompatibility issues and limited playback formats. I suspect that the WDTV would suffer from the same limitations. To much competition in the market place. i give Western digital 12 months before they drop all development and support of the UI
My suggestion would be to go with the Mac Mini run with a USB to and external DAC; the Benchmark is a slam dunk in my opinion.
For the UI load Plex currently in pre-release but its interface is gorgeous, plays back video and referecnes your itunes library